795 views

 

Submit

  • Uploaded on 2/07/2012 6:53:20 PM
  • Category: AFL

Tags: mrp panel review

Rate This Video:
0 (0)

All Comments (36)

  • jackoiswacko42 Says:

    6/07/2012 12:31:56 PM

    How does Goddard get two and Simon Black get none for smashing Picken in the nose? MRP is an absolute joke. They go hand in hand with the disgraceful umpiring...

  • ihasadodo Says:

    4/07/2012 1:14:14 PM

    still buddy's tackle was a SLING TACKLE the free kick was given because it was a sling tackle he was reported because it was a sling tackle if the AFL wants to get rid of sling tackles give them weeks for the tackle not the injury its given. the match review panel should be consistent, one tackle classed as a sling should get the same punishment as the other.

  • ViolentSpring Says:

    3/07/2012 7:49:21 PM

    Last week, they scolded players to not touch umpires when you almost crash into them when it's the umpire does not move out of way.

  • invisiblebutterfly6 Says:

    3/07/2012 7:33:48 PM

    MRP is inconsistent with their decisions...kind of defeats the purpose of having one :/

  • TheTribe81 Says:

    3/07/2012 2:13:36 PM

    Walker got three weeks, it was a wreak less tackle, that said if walker gets three weeks, Shane Mcinerney should get six, it was a deplorable display of umpiring, that decision allowed Adelaide to have a shot on goal and kick it, after the tackle, it was just one of many poor decisions throughout the game, Mcinerney really needs to answer for his many bad calls during the game ...

  • behappyproductions09 Says:

    3/07/2012 1:46:50 PM

    walker deserved that because that was a dangerous tackle, even the NRL conisder that tackle dangerous

  • 50centindaclub Says:

    3/07/2012 12:10:32 PM

    they are just looking for someone to suspend each week, cant believe how ridiculous some of these are.

  • rscacco89 Says:

    3/07/2012 11:42:39 AM

    @ihasadodo the umps are scared to ban buddy

  • xxdaddycoolxx1 Says:

    3/07/2012 8:55:19 AM

    @SGCGamersNetwork He broke the guys jaw and now he's out for 4 weeks and you think that's ok? The rules state if you bump and you make contact to the head your in trouble. We might not like the rules but the players have to follow them

  • xxdaddycoolxx1 Says:

    3/07/2012 8:53:03 AM

    @ihasadodo Can you read? The report stated walker was charged with a dangerous tackle not a sling tackle

  • SGCGamersNetwork Says:

    3/07/2012 8:05:03 AM

    You have got to be kidding me with Crameri's one, he kicked it and then he bumped. I can understand a free kick but is a two week suspension, really? Is this what footy has got to now? All I can say to the MRP IS TOUGHEN UP PRINCESS!!!!!!!!!!!!! Footy's a contact sport!

  • Binij1 Says:

    3/07/2012 2:27:17 AM

    those who reckon guerra and walker should not have got suspended are off their head.....both had the potential to break necks. The Goddard one though was too harsh

  • Barragwanus Says:

    3/07/2012 1:34:22 AM

    How embarrassing is this sport becoming, I can understand the MRP protecting the players welfare and such but all of these suspensions are an absolute joke. Walkers tackle was outstanding. And Dane Swan got away with exactly the same thing, funny that. Go the Dons!

  • Stoigen86 Says:

    3/07/2012 12:51:42 AM

    What's bizarre is that Walker got a free kick for HTB so the umpire saw nothing bad in it. The Guerra one is absolute crap three weeks for that? I mean Ballantyne can take out players off the ball and only get a week. So what the AFL are saying is that high contact going for the ball is three times worse than gutless thuggery. Mark Fraser you are an absolute imbecile.

  • Jamesderman Says:

    3/07/2012 12:07:07 AM

    Walkers impact was upgraded to medium based partly on the medical report from richmond. Also Walker's tackle ended up making Morris land much more heavily on the ground also on his head as well. And Walker's tackling motion was not as flowing as Buddy's which sort've indicates to the MRP that he knew it was a dangerous tackle (With Buddy's he tackled in one smooth motion and didn't really know that the guy had let go of the ball).

  • Operative34 Says:

    2/07/2012 11:50:22 PM

    A lot of this seems soft, especially Abletts. That shouldn't even be considered

  • JJB22109 Says:

    2/07/2012 11:48:40 PM

    Damn it Goddard ruining my supercoach team...

  • Kiara McCallion Says:

    2/07/2012 11:37:59 PM

    Are they serious with Ablett? Oh my god, get over it. Football is meant to be rough and players trip over all the time.

  • Insidious1933 Says:

    2/07/2012 11:12:53 PM

    There's a lot of hard men on here so hard and tough they could take worse. Get over yourselves!

  • thenormoshow Says:

    2/07/2012 11:02:10 PM

    This is so soft like wtf

Show more comments
Search By: